NYT Article Links Nursing Home Staffing Mandate Repeal to MAGA Donations, Trump Private Meeting

Nursing home leaders pushed – with donations to the Trump campaign – to have the federal nursing home staffing mandate repealed permanently, arguing the rule would raise costs and force facilities to close.

According to a report in the New York Times, about 40 corporate entities associated with nursing homes across the country donated nearly $4.8 million to MAGA Inc., a pro-Trump super PAC, from August through mid-September, while top donors including subsidiaries of the Ensign Group (Nasdaq: ENSG), PruittHealth, NHS Management and Saber Healthcare Group met privately in August with President Trump at his golf club for lunch, urging him to repeal the rule.

Soon after the lunch and donations, the administration stopped defending the staffing rule in court and later fully revoked it, citing workforce shortages and burdens on rural facilities, the NYT reported.

Advertisement

The White House denied any connection between donations and policy decisions.

American Health Care Association and National Center for Assisted Living (AHCA/NCAL) President and CEO Clifton J. Porter II attended the lunch meeting as well. Fundraising for super PACs is a departure for well-established national trade groups like AHCA/NCAL, who usually seek support from both parties, the NYT reported.

AHCA/NCAL has represented the nursing home industry’s interests for more than 75 years.

Advertisement

Rachel Reeves, a spokeswoman for AHCA/NCAL, told the NYT that the group “appreciated the opportunity to speak with the president directly and foster an open dialogue with the administration,” while also emphasizing the association’s nonpartisanship. Reeves denied the lunch focused on the staffing rule or possible Medicaid cuts, a contradiction from others in attendance, the article noted. 

Former AHCA/NCAL leader Mark Parkinson countered in a blog post that the mandate was “already dead” before the industry’s meeting with Trump, noting multiple federal judges ruling that the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) exceeded its authority to implement the rule, with Congress imposing the 10-year moratorium on the staffing provisions.

Parkinson, who now serves as CEO of long-term care web platform Park Place Live, defended political advocacy by the nursing home industry as normal and necessary, and that other groups including labor unions engaged in similar political activity without comparable scrutiny.

“The Service Employees International Union (SEIU) spent tens of millions and possibly hundreds of millions on the Biden campaigns in 2020 and 2024. It then became a major advocate for the staffing proposal,” Parkinson added.

“The biggest loss of the entire saga was the opportunity cost. We learned so much during the pandemic. We were and are anxious to grow RN and infection control presence in facilities,” Parkinson said. “Instead, we were forced to fight an impossible-to-implement mandate that would have shut many of us down. We did and we won, and we did it all before the president’s lunch in August of 2025.”

Looking back at the twists and turns since the rule was introduced by the Biden administration, patient advocates said the rule was necessary to protect millions of seniors – a demographic that helped Trump clinch another term. The staffing rule could have saved 13,000 lives of nursing residents per year, according to a report published in February by the Leonard Davis Institute of Health Economics, University of Pennsylvania.

A study published in August 2023, conducted by Abt Associates and commissioned by CMS, found that no solitary staffing measure could ensure high-quality care. Researchers also said elevated staffing levels would result in reduced hospitalizations and emergency room admissions, faster care delivery and a decrease in instances of care omission.

AHCA/NCAL said in May 2024 that the rule would cost an estimated $6.5 billion per year and require an additional 102,000 clinicians – 77,000 certified nurse aides (CNAs) and 24,000 registered nurses (RNs). About 290,000 residents would be at risk of displacement, with 95% of nursing homes saying they would not be able to meet the mandate standards at the time.

The rule required operators to staff their buildings so 3.5 hours of care could be provided to each patient per day; the rule also had a requirement for an RN to be on-site 24/7.

A 2024 report by the National Bureau of Economic Research found that more than 60% of nursing home profits were hidden in a “maze of transactions” among related corporations, the NYT reported, and that if those funds were spent on staff, nearly 76% of facilities could meet the 24-hour RN requirement under the mandate.

Companies featured in this article:

, , , , , , ,